Amish Butter

Amish Butter | Creamy, Rich, & Traditionally Churned

Experience the unbeatable flavor and texture of Amish Roll Butter, made the old-fashioned way in small batches with high-quality cream. Known for its extra creamy texture, higher butterfat content, and distinctive flavor, our Amish butter is a favorite for home bakers, chefs, and butter lovers alike.

Whether you're spreading it on fresh bread, baking your favorite recipes, or enhancing everyday meals, Wisconsin River Meats’ Amish Butter brings premium quality and traditional flavor to your kitchen.

Why Choose Amish Butter?

Old-Fashioned, Handcrafted Tradition

Our Amish butter is churned in small batches using traditional methods passed down for generations. The result? A dense, creamy texture and flavor that puts supermarket butter to shame.

Higher Butterfat, Richer Flavor

With higher butterfat content (82–85%), Amish roll butter offers a richer, more luxurious taste and consistency—perfect for cooking, baking, or simply enjoying on toast.

Rolled, Salted & Ready to Slice

Each roll is shaped the classic way and lightly salted to enhance natural flavor. It’s easy to portion, store, and enjoy however you like.

Perfect for Every Use

  • Homemade baking (cookies, pie crusts, pastries)

  • Spreading on fresh bread or dinner rolls

  • Finishing steaks, vegetables, or pasta

  • Building charcuterie and breakfast boards

  • Gourmet gifts for food lovers

Experience Real Amish Quality

We’re proud to offer Amish-made butter that reflects the quality and care of traditional craftsmanship. From the heart of dairy country, our butter brings real flavor to every bite.

Order Amish Butter Online Today

Ready to taste the difference? Stock up on real Amish roll butter and elevate your kitchen with premium, small-batch quality.

Shop Amish Butter Now »